Student Solution

-->

"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world”
– Nelson Mandela

1 University

1 Course

3 Subjects

Chapter 27- Discussion Question

Chapter 27- Discussion Question

Q 27-1: Discuss the standard of care traditionally required of the bailee for the bailed property in each of the following situations and determine whether the bailee breached that duty. (See Bailments.) 1. Ricardo borrows Steve’s lawn mower because his own lawn mower needs repair. Ricardo mows his front yard. To mow the backyard, he needs to move some hoses and lawn furniture. He leaves the mower in front of his house while doing so. When he returns to the front yard, he discovers that the mower has been stolen. 2. Alicia owns a valuable speedboat. She is going on vacation and asks her neighbor, Maureen, to store the boat in one stall of Maureen’s double garage. Maureen consents, and the boat is moved into the garage. Maureen needs some grocery items for dinner and drives to the store. She leaves the garage door open while she is gone, as is her custom, and the speedboat is stolen during that time.

Q 27-2: Jaspal has a severe heart attack and is taken to the hospital. He is aware that he is not expected to live. Because he is a bachelor with no close relatives nearby, Jaspal gives his car keys to his close friend Friedrich, telling Friedrich that he is expected to die and that the car is Friedrich’s. Jaspal survives the heart attack, but two months later he dies from pneumonia. Sam, Jaspal’s uncle and the executor of his estate, wants Friedrich to return the car. Friedrich refuses, claiming that the car was a gift from Jaspal. Discuss whether Friedrich will be required to return the car to Jaspal’s estate.27-5: Vincent Slavin was a partner at Cantor Fitzgerald Securities in the World Trade Center (WTC) in New York City. In 1998, Slavin and Anna Baez became engaged and began living together. They placed both of their names on three accounts at Chase Manhattan Bank according to the bank’s terms, which provided that “accounts with multiple owners are joint, payable to either owner or the survivor.” Slavin arranged for the direct deposit of his salary and commissions into one of the accounts. On September 11, 2001, Slavin died when two planes piloted by terrorists crashed into the WTC towers, causing their collapse. At the time, the balance in the three accounts was $656,944.36. On September 14, Cantor Fitzgerald deposited an additional $58,264.73 into the direct-deposit account. Baez soon withdrew the entire amount from all of the accounts. Mary Jelnek, Slavin’s mother, filed a suit against Baez to determine the ownership of the funds that had been in the accounts. In what form of ownership were the accounts held? Who is entitled to which of the funds and why?

View Related Questions

Solution Preview

In context to the provided scenario and in context to the first question, I would say that Yes, Mr. Ricardo did make a breach upon the contractual duty as he did take a mower for that particular time period. He did lost this due to his own negligence that is considered as liable for making payments for the loss of the mower. Even he had to make payments for the breach of his individual duty just as the Bailee (Gupta, 2018).